- Email:
- jmadeira@indiana.edu
- Phone:
- (812) 856-1082
- Location:
- Baier Hall 314
Education
- Millersville University of Pennsylvania B.A. 1997
- Georgetown University M.S. 1999
- University of Pennsylvania Law School J.D. 2003
- University of Pennsylvania Annenberg School for Comm. Ph.D. 2007
Background
- Earned her J.D. magna cum laude from the University of Pennsylvania School of Law; elected to the Order of the Coif; and served as Senior Articles Editor for the University of Pennsylvania Journal of Constitutional Law
- Clerk, Hon. Richard D. Cudahy, U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit, Chicago (2004-2005)
- Climenko Fellow and Lecturer on Law, Harvard University (2005-2007)
- Research Associate, Capital Punishment Research Initiative, University of Albany School of Criminal Justice
- Recipient, Federalist Society Searle Young Legal Scholars Research Fellowship, 2011-12
- Recipient, Indiana University Trustees' Teaching Award, 2015
- “Shooting Blanks: What Happens When Law Can’t Keep Up With Technology” (TEDx Zurich, December 2020)
- Recipient, Indiana University Leon Wallace Teaching Award, 2022
- Author, coauthor, or editor of 5 published and forthcoming books:
- Killing McVeigh: The Death Penalty and the Myth of Closure (NYU Press, 2012)
- Taking Baby Steps: How Patients and Fertility Clinics Collaborate in Conception (California UP, 2018)
- The Edward Elgar Research Handbook of Law and Emotion (Edward Elgar, 2021)
- Indiana Personal Injury Law Treatise (Lexis Nexis, 2023)
- The Second Amendment: Gun Rights and Regulation (co-edited with Jacob D. Charles, Joseph Blocher, and Darrell Miller) (Foundation Press, forthcoming)
Biography
Professor Madeira joined the Indiana Law faculty in 2007. She is an internationally recognized expert in fertility fraud, bioethics, and law and medicine, with a focus on reproductive endocrinology. Her research has received profiled in national and international media, including the Netflix documentary “Our Father” (2022) to TED to investigative news programs like “20/20” (2019). Her research interests involve empirical research; the role of emotion in law; the sociology of law; law, medicine, and bioethics; and the Second Amendment.
Madeira is the author, coauthor, or editor of dozens of scholarly articles and three published book and two forthcoming titles, including the forthcoming Indiana Personal Injury Law Treatise (forthcoming 2023) and a forthcoming casebook, The Second Amendment: Gun Rights and Regulation (co-edited with Jacob D. Charles, Joseph Blocher, and Darrell Miller) (Foundation Press, forthcoming)
Most recently, she co-edited The Edward Elgar Research Handbook of Law and Emotion (Edward Elgar, 2021).
Her second book, Taking Baby Steps: How Patients and Fertility Clinics Collaborate in Conception (University of California Press, 2018), takes readers inside the infertility experience, from dealing with infertility-related emotions to forming treatment relationships with medical professionals, confronting difficult decisions, and negotiating informed consent. Based on a wealth of qualitative and quantitative data (130 patient interviews, 83 interviews with reproductive medical professionals, and 267 patient surveys), Madeira investigates how women, men, and their care providers can utilize trust to collaboratively negotiate infertility’s personal, physical, spiritual, ethical, medical, and legal minefields.
Madeira’s first book, Killing McVeigh: The Death Penalty and the Myth of Closure, applies collective memory to criminal prosecution and sentencing, exploring the ways in which victims' families and survivors came to comprehend and cope with the Oklahoma City bombing through membership in community groups as well as through attending and participating in Timothy McVeigh's trial and execution.
Madeira also specializes in assessing how multimedia technology can improve patient education and decision making. She is principal investigator on a grant (with Dr. Basia Andraka-Christou) to design and implement S.U.N., a multimedia web portal integrating educational videos and a mobile health tracking application for college students that addresses alcohol, marijuana, opioid, and stimulant use disorders. In addition, she is involved in assessing the efficacy of commercially available applications in reproductive medicine, gastroenterology, and other areas of medical practice.
Finally, Madeira is currently involved in a research project assessing how Americans talk about firearms and associated benefits, risks, rights, and regulations, especially how doctor-patient discussions of firearm ownership and access impact treatment relationships and the provision of medical care across practice fields. In prior publications, Madeira has investigated a wide variety of topics, including the effects of legal proceedings, verdicts, and sentences upon victims' families; the role of empathy in personal injury litigation; law and semiotics; and the impact of recent developments in capital victims' services upon the relationship between victims' families and the criminal justice system.
After graduating from law school and completing her Ph.D. coursework, Professor Madeira clerked for the Hon. Richard D. Cudahy at the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit. She then came to Harvard as a Climenko Fellow and lecturer in law, where she taught legal research and writing as well as a seminar on the cultural life of capital punishment. Madeira also recently served as a research associate at the Capital Punishment Research Initiative at the School of Criminal Justice, University at Albany, State University of New York.
In The Media
- Quoted in "Greenwood shooting prompts questions: Incident puts spotlight on changes to Indiana gun laws," The Indiana Lawyer ( 08-03-2022 )
- Wrote "What Abortion Ruling Means for Assisted Reproductive Technologies," Bloomberg Law ( 07-25-2022 )
- Quoted in "Legal, medical experts oppose Indiana’s proposed abortion bill as ‘terribly restrictive’," Chicago Tribune ( 07-24-2022 )
- Mentioned in "Op-Ed: Why I’m racing to thaw my embryos," Baltimore Sun ( 07-22-2022 )
- Quoted in "Doctors, hospitals face confusion about abortions," Indiana Business Journal ( 07-22-2022 )
- Quoted in "What is in Indiana’s proposed abortion legislation? A legal expert has some answers," Indiana Public Radio ( 07-21-2022 )
- Quoted in "Indiana lawmakers to debate new restrictive abortion law next week," The Bharat Express News ( 07-21-2022 )
- Quoted in "Here's what current Indiana abortion law states," WPTA 21 News ( 07-20-2022 )
- Quoted in "Gun violence should be considered public health crisis, not political debate, experts say," WRTV News ( 07-19-2022 )
- Quoted in "'He definitely saved lives no doubt about it' Prosecutors, legal experts say person who shot Greenwood Mall suspect was justified," WTHI-TV 10 ( 07-19-2022 )
- Quoted in "An armed bystander shot & killed the Greenwood mall shooting suspect. Did he break the law?," Indianapolis Star ( 07-19-2022 )
- Quoted in "Gun-makers have long been shielded from liability after mass shootings. That’s starting to change -- and Highland Park has noticed.," Chicago Tribune ( 07-18-2022 )
- Quoted in "Rampage in Indiana a rare instance of armed civilian ending mass shooting," Washington Post ( 07-18-2022 )
- Quoted in "Indiana GOP prepares new abortion laws but won’t reveal plans publicly ahead of special session," Fox 19 News ( 07-14-2022 )
- Quoted in "Council votes 7-0 to create committee to address gun violence, but only two members agree to join," Chicago Tribune ( 07-12-2022 )
- Quoted in "2021 saw most abortions in Indiana in 10 years," WISH TV News ( 07-07-2022 )
- Quoted in "Abortion bans could impact access to IVF after Roe v. Wade overturned, experts say," Yahoo News ( 07-07-2022 )
- Quoted in "How overturning Roe v. Wade could affect IVF," Yahoo News ( 07-07-2022 )
- Quoted in "What to know about mifepristone, misoprostol access in Indiana — and how it could change," Indianapolis Star ( 07-07-2022 )
- Quoted in "What Gun Reform May Mean for HR," SHRM ( 07-06-2022 )
- Quoted in "Abortion pill poses legislative challenges," Tribune-Star ( 07-01-2022 )
- Quoted in "Abortion criminalization could weaponize personal data," Indiana Public Media ( 06-27-2022 )
- Quoted in "How much of an impact will overturning Roe V. Wade have on midterm election? Experts weigh in," WPTA News ( 06-27-2022 )
- Quoted in "Abortion is still technically legal in Indiana. Here's what current law states," WTHR News ( 06-27-2022 )
- Quoted in "'The worst-case scenario': what IU experts have to say about a post-Roe world," Indiana Daily Student ( 06-27-2022 )
- Coauthored "Red flag laws can be a lifeline for our children and youth," The Hill ( 06-24-2022 )
- Quoted in "What to know about abortion access in Bloomington now, and in the future," The Herald Times ( 06-24-2022 )
- Quoted in "Local governments have limited options for addressing gun violence, but community partnerships a possibility: experts," Chicago Tribute ( 06-24-2022 )
- Quoted in "Supreme Court's decision to overturn Roe v. Wade leaves Indiana's abortion laws in question," CBS 2 Chicago News ( 06-24-2022 )
- Quoted in "Why fertility doctors get away with using their own sperm," Fox 17 News ( 06-15-2022 )
- Quoted in "How 'red flag' laws work in the DMV," WUSA 9 News ( 06-10-2022 )
- Quoted in "Indiana's red flag law deemed more lenient than most - find out why that is," WLFI News ( 06-08-2022 )
- Quoted in "A fertility doctor used his own sperm to secretly get patients pregnant. A lawyer working with the victims is now pushing to make fertility fraud a criminal offense," Insider ( 06-07-2022 )
- Quoted in "In most cases, gun makers cannot be sued if their gun was used in a crime," WUSA 9 ( 06-02-2022 )
- Quoted in "Colorado becomes first state to ban anonymous sperm and egg donations," Canon City Daily Record ( 06-01-2022 )
- Quoted in "The 19th Explains: How would overturning Roe v. Wade affect IVF?," The 19th ( 05-27-2022 )
- Quoted in "IU Expert on Gun Violence," Times of India ( 05-26-2022 )
- Quoted in "Abortion restrictions likely coming to Indiana if draft opinion is published," The Indiana Lawyer ( 05-25-2022 )
- Quoted in "Uvalde School Shooting: Where do we go from here?," Indiana Public Media ( 05-25-2022 )
- Quoted in "Netflix's 'Our Father' Is A Horror Story Of Legal Failure," Above the Law ( 05-18-2022 )
- Quoted in "Abortion Wars: A U.S. more divided and less safe for women?," Tribune-Star ( 05-17-2022 )
- Interviewed in "Donald Cline Legal Explainer," FOX 59 News ( 05-12-2022 )
- Quoted in "The Fertility Fraud Victims From 'Our Father' Are Paving New Legal Ground," Jezebel ( 05-11-2022 )
- Quoted in "Roe v. Wade: How will the possible overturn affect you?," WPTA 21 News ( 05-06-2022 )
- Coauthored "Sophistry at the Supreme Court," The Hill ( 05-06-2022 )
- Quoted in "Will Indiana enact a 'trigger law' if Roe v. Wade is overturned?," CBS 2 News ( 05-04-2022 )
- Quoted in "The history of Roe V. Wade and the United States Supreme Court's decision," WTHI News ( 05-03-2022 )
- Quoted in "IU prof: Alito intends draft opinion as 'opening salvo in a cultural war'," WISH News ( 05-03-2022 )
- Quoted in "Why experts say Indiana is prepped to ban abortion if Roe v. Wade is overturned," WTHR News ( 05-03-2022 )
- Quoted in "Hoosier primary results could impact abortion law rewrite," CBS4 News ( 05-03-2022 )
- Quoted in "Legal experts weigh in on leaked draft opinion against abortion," ABC 57 ( 05-03-2022 )
- Quoted in "Jury awards nearly $9M to families in fertility fraud case," ABC News ( 04-29-2022 )
- Quoted in "Jury awards nearly $9M to families in fertility fraud case," My Northwest ( 04-29-2022 )
- Quoted in "Jury awards nearly $9 million to families suing Colorado fertility doctor who used own sperm to impregnate patients," Denver Post ( 04-29-2022 )
- Quoted in "Gymnasts Molested By Olympic Team Doc Larry Nassar File Negligence Claims Against FBI Over Botched Investigation," American Greatness ( 04-21-2022 )
- Quoted in "Loophole in Indiana red flag law comes under fire," WISH News ( 04-15-2022 )
- Quoted in "'Fertility Fraud' now a felony in Kentucky after Gov. Beshear signs bill into law," WHAS News ( 04-11-2022 )
- Quoted in "Marion County Prosecutor joins law enforcement in opposing constitutional carry bill," WRTV ( 03-09-2022 )
- Interviewed for "Fertility fraud bill aimed at holding doctors criminally accountable passes Kentucky House judiciary," WHAS ( 03-02-2022 )
- Mentioned in "House Bill 1077 would allow anyone 18 or older to carry a handgun without a permit," WBIW ( 02-23-2022 )
- Quoted in "Indiana Chamber leader praises Supreme Court ruling on COVID vaccinations," WISH News ( 01-13-2022 )
- Quoted in "Three Rochester doctors suspected of impregnating women with own sperm," Democrat and Chronicle ( 12-07-2021 )
- Quoted in "Fertility doctor admits to inseminating women with his own sperm – but keeps licence," Daily Star (UK) ( 10-19-2021 )
- Quoted in "Fertility fraud exposed in Louisville: Doctor admits to using his own sperm to inseminate patients," WHAS News ( 09-30-2021 )
- Quoted in "Woman suing Indianapolis hospital that refuses to give her mother ivermectin for COVID treatment," WTHR News ( 09-30-2021 )
- Quoted in "Fertility fraud against women seeking help from their doctor has long painful history," Rochester Democrat and Chronicle ( 09-22-2021 )
- Quoted in "IU experts say Biden's new vaccine mandates for large businesses protect employees' safety," Indiana Daily Student ( 09-14-2021 )
- Quoted in "Law professor says Biden vaccine mandate is 'completely constitutional'," WDRB News ( 09-10-2021 )
- Quoted in "DNA Test Reveals Unexplainable Fertility Clinic Mix-Up; Families Seek Damages," Above the Law ( 09-01-2021 )
- Quoted in "Biden's requirement of COVID-19 vaccinations or testing for federal workers is legal, experts say," Fox 59 ( 07-29-2021 )
- Quoted in "A 22-year-old lawsuit may generate unprecedented access to gun industry secrets," The Trace ( 07-15-2021 )
- Quoted in "'All part of the bargain': Hoosiers respond to dismissal of complaint against hospital's vaccine requirement," The Indiana Lawyer ( 07-07-2021 )
- Quoted in "Indiana nursing homes legally protected amid soaring Medicare death rates," Indiana Public Media ( 06-24-2021 )
- Quoted in "Inseminated by doctor who used own sperm, woman says conduct 'unconscionable and depraved'," Louisville Courier-Journal (Sub. Req.) ( 06-23-2021 )
- Quoted in "Marion County businesses react to loosening restrictions on masks, capacity," Fox 59 ( 06-08-2021 )
- Quoted in "Lawmakers challenge IU's COVID-19 immunization requirement," Indiana Public Media ( 05-24-2021 )
- Quoted in "COVID-19 vaccination cards could act as proof to remove masks," Fox 59 ( 05-18-2021 )
- Quoted in "Critics say Indiana COVID-19 law allows nursing home neglect," The Associated Press ( 05-08-2021 )
- Quoted in "Judge gives police 48 hours to report taking firearms from anyone considered a danger," WISH-TV ( 05-07-2021 )
- Quoted in "Holcomb signs COVID-19 liability protections that critics say will allow nursing home neglect," The Indianapolis Star ( 05-01-2021 )
- Quoted in "Does this Indiana bill awaiting Holcomb's signature let nursing homes get away with neglect?," The Indianapolis Star ( 04-23-2021 )
- Quoted in "Does Indiana have the strongest red flag law in the country?," WTHR ( 04-22-2021 )
- Quoted in "What justice may look like in the FedEx shooting," WIBC ( 04-18-2021 )
- Quoted in "Mass shootings are on the rise again," WTHI ( 04-17-2021 )
- Quoted in "Opinion: Children are not protected in Indiana's justice system. SB 368 can change that.," Indiana Daily Student ( 04-01-2021 )
- Quoted in "N4T investigators: Fertility bill passes House Judiciary Committee," KVOA Tucson ( 03-11-2021 )
- Quoted in "An Indiana House bill could make access to abortion harder in the state," Indiana Daily Student ( 03-05-2021 )
- Quoted in "Is deceased Cincinnati fertility doctor the missing link for these newly discovered half-siblings?," WCPO 9 ( 03-03-2021 )
- Quoted in "Indiana legislature debates bill that would allow Hoosiers to carry handguns without permits," Indiana Daily Student ( 02-11-2021 )
- Quoted in "Bill to repeal the need for a license to carry a handgun awaits committee action," The StatehouseFile.com ( 02-11-2021 )
- Quoted in "Should Indiana eliminate gun carry permits?," Fox 59 ( 02-10-2021 )
- Quoted in "Indiana lawmakers suggest getting rid of gun carry permits," CBS 4 ( 02-10-2021 )
- Quoted in "COVID-19 Liability Protection Bill passes Indiana Senate, prompting concern from some workers," Indiana Public Media ( 01-29-2021 )
- Quoted in "Fertility doctors used their sperm to get patients pregnant. The children want justice," Vice ( 01-06-2021 )
- Quoted in "At-home DNA tests bring reckoning to illicit fertility doctors," Bloomberg Law ( 12-23-2020 )
- Quoted in "What shocking revelation emerged while 'Baby God' filmmaker worked on documentary about infamous fertility doctor?," Oxygen ( 12-04-2020 )
- Quoted in "Texas doctor fathered 7 children with fertility patients because frozen donor sperm wasn't working," Newsweek ( 11-25-2020 )
- Quoted in "Texas fertility doctor fathered 7 children by patients under his care, at-home DNA kits show," WFAA ( 11-24-2020 )
- Quoted in "Woman uncovers family secret, DNA test results trace father back to mother's fertility doctor," CBS 8 ( 11-17-2020 )
- Quoted in "N4T investigators: Fertility fraud?," KVOA ( 11-12-2020 )
- Quoted in "Home DNA test uncovers secret: Fertility doctor accused of using his own sperm on Washington patient," KIRO 7 News ( 11-09-2020 )
- Quoted in "IVF and sex: How the treatment hurts couples' sex lives," The Huffington Post ( 11-01-2020 )
- Wrote an article titled "VOTE -- What's at stake: Guns," Bloom Magazine ( 10-13-2020 )
- Quoted in "Bar owners are suing over COVID restrictions. Here's why ruling in their favor is unlikely," The Indianapolis Star ( 09-24-2020 )
- Mentioned in "Fertility fraud filings flourish...and the facts get funkier," Above The Law ( 09-23-2020 )
- Quoted in "Conception deception," Texas Observer ( 09-15-2020 )
- Quoted in "Why doesn't Indiana punish violators of its coronavirus mask mandate?," Indiana Public Media ( 08-20-2020 )
Selected Works
- A Secret Weapon?: Applying Privacy Doctrine to the Second Amendment, 46 HASTINGS CONSTITUTIONAL LAW QUARTERLY 555 (2019).
- Uncommon Misconceptions: Holding Physicians Accountable for Insemination Fraud, 37 LAW & INEQUALITY 45 (2019).
- TAKING BABY STEPS: HOW PATIENTS AND FERTILITY CLINICS COLLABORATE IN CONCEPTION. Oakland, CA: University of California Press, 2018.
- Against Seminal Principles: Ethics, Hubris, and Lessons to Learn from Illicit Inseminations(with Steven R. Lindheim and Mark V. Sauer), 110 FERTILITY AND STERILITY 1003 (Nov. 2018).
- Informed Consent: More than Just "Sign Here"(with Kathryn Coyne, et.al.), 108 FERTILITY AND STERILITY 40 (July 2017).
- Buyers in the Baby Market: Toward a Transparent Consumerism(with June Carbone), 91 WASHINGTON LAW REVIEW 71 (2016)
- Jody Lyneé Madeira, “The Ghosts in the Machinery of Death: The Rhetoric of Mistake in Lethal Injection Reform,” in Law's Mistakes (Austin Sarat, Lawrence Douglas & Martha Umphrey eds., University of Massachusetts Press) (2016)
- Jody Lyneé Madeira, Laying bin Laden to Rest, in The In/Visibility of America's 21st Century Wars (Jon Simons and John Lucaites eds.) (2016)
- June Carbone & Jody Lyneé Madeira, The Acceptability of Surrogacy, Washington Law Review Online (Spring 2015)
- Jody Lyneé Madeira, Conceiving of Products and the Products of Conception: Theoretical Reflections on Commodification, Consumption, ART, and Abortion, ____ J. of Law, Medicine & Ethics ___ (May 2015)
- Nicole K. Smith, Jody Madeira, & Heather Millard, Sexual Function and Fertility Quality of Life in Women Using In Vitro Fertilization, Journal of Sexual Medicine (2015)
- Jeanna M. Mastrocinque, Jed W. Metzger, Jody Madeira, Kay Lang, Heather Pruss, Peter K. Navratil, Marla Sandys, & Catherine Cerulli, I'm Still Left Here With the Pain: Exploring the Health Consequences of Homicide on Families and Friends, Homicide Studies (June 2014)
- Aborted Emotions: Regret and Relationality, 21 Mich. J. Gender & L. 1 (2014).
- Clear and Ever-Present Dangers? Redefining “Closure” in a Post-9-11 World, Capital Punishment: Part of a Sustainable Criminal Justice System? (Lill Scherdin ed., Ashgate Press, 2014)
- KILLING McVEIGH: THE DEATH PENALTY AND THE MYTH OF CLOSURE (NYU Press, June 2012)
- "Woman Scorned?: Resurrecting Infertile Women's Decision-Making Autonomy," 71 MD. L. REV. 339 (2012)
- "The Family Capital of Capital Families: Investigating Empathic Connections Between Jurors and Defendants' Families in Death Penalty Cases" ___ MICH. ST. L. REV. (2012).
- "The Visibly Offensive Offender: A Semiotic Phenomenology of an Execution," LAW, CULTURE, AND VISUAL STUDIES (Richard Sherwin & Anne Wagner eds.) (Springer, 2012).
- "Conceivable Changes: Effectuating Infertile Couples' Emotional Ties to Frozen Embryos Through New Disposition Options," 79 U. MO. KANSAS CITY L. REV. 315 (2010) (invited contribution to the Global Issues in Family Law Symposium at University of Missouri, Kansas City Law School).
- "Why Rebottle the Genie?": Capitalizing on 'Closure' in the Capital Punishment Context, 85 IND. L. J. 1477 (2010).
- When It's So Hard to Relate: Can the Legal System Mitigate the Trauma of Victim-Offender Relationships?, 46 HOUSTON L. REV. 401 (2009)
- Blood Relations: Collective Memory, Cultural Trauma, and the Prosecution and Execution of Timothy McVeigh, 45 STUDIES IN LAW, POLITICS AND SOCIETY 75 (2008)
- Recognizing Odysseus' Scar: Reconceptualizing Pain and Its Empathic Role in Civil Adjudication, 34 FLA. ST. U. L. REV. 41 (2006)
- Lashing Reason to the Mast: Understanding Judicial Constraints on Emotion in Personal Injury Litigation, 40 UC DAVIS L. REV. 137 (2006)
- Pained Sympathy for Sympathy Pains: The Reasoned Morality of Empathy in Adjudicating Suffering, 58 S.C. L. REV. 415 (2006)
- The Execution as Sacrifice, in EVIL, LAW, AND THE STATE: PERSPECTIVES ON STATE POWER AND VIOLENCE (John T. Parry, ed., 2006)
- A Constructed Peace: Narratives of Suture in the News Media, CANADIAN JOURNAL OF LAW AND SOCIETY 19:2 (2004) (peer-reviewed)
Areas of Expertise
- Assisted reproductive technology
- Children and the law
- Health law
- Second Amendment
- Torts